"SEGA All Stars Knock Out"?

[HyperVoiceActing]

I've been talking to some of the people at CVG and one thing led to another and I decided to flesh out my idea of a SEGA fighting game. Anyone wanna talk about the idea and throw around some things to add to it? I made a little roster up already:

Sonic the Hedgehog - Miles "Tails" Prower
Knuckles the Echidna - Amy Rose
Dr Eggman (mid boss)
Akira Yuri - Sarah Bryant
Axel Stone - Blaze Fielding
NiGHTs - Ristar
Beat - Sketch Turner
Joe Musashi - Altered Beast
Sakura Shinguji - Ichigo Ogami
Gilius Thunderhead - Tyris Blaze
Death Adder (final boss)
Vyse - Alis
Pulseman - Vectorman
Alex Kidd - Billy Hatcher
Red - Blue
Ryo Hazuki - Bahn
Segata Senshiro (secret final boss; if you beat him you unlock him to play)

CHARS NEED OF PARTNER
Jack Cayman
Bayonetta
Astal

[Dead Phoenix]

 
Could I suggest a monster or boss from House of the Dead?

[DanOwnsall112]

Thomas Rogan (house of the dead)?

[HyperVoiceActing]

Sure thing. I'll add him in

[G.P.O.A - GatlingPunchRalf]

If you want someone else from the Jet Set series, may I suggest Yoyo or Gum? They're both staples of the series like Beat is.

[HyperVoiceActing]

I know but apparently Beat is more popular 

[G.P.O.A - GatlingPunchRalf]

I know but apparently Beat is more popular 

From people I've talked to, Yoyo and oddly Combo have pretty big fanbases as well.

[SanjiSasuke]

You might want to look at Centurion (from Altered Beast) for MUGEN. He could fit in, depending on how you re making it.

I think it would be best if it played reminiscent of their own games, but also added combat more like a fighting game.

[HyperVoiceActing]

Well since a lot of SEGA's franchises have different kinds of gameplay, I'm not sure how it could work

Also, added Sketch Turner

[ExeLord]

Dunno, looking at roster makes me want two separate games rather then one.
Sketch, Blaze, Jillius, Ryo and so on looks realistic and Sonic, Ristar, Alex Kidd, Vectorman and others(you may add Sparkster, Zero the Kamikaze Squirrel, Aero the Acro-Bat, Pulseman, Zool) are cartoonish.
The only one, who can actually break the wall between those clashing styles is Sketch(well, maybe some sonic evildoer can, but I dunno, it's not for my liking, very used) - if you are going to make one game with both humans and cartoonish animals in it it's not a bad idea to make story around Sketch, with him and some other people from real world being transferred into bizarre comix world... or something like this.

[Silva-silva]

Dunno, looking at roster makes me want two separate games rather then one.
Sketch, Blaze, Jillius, Ryo and so on looks realistic and Sonic, Ristar, Alex Kidd, Vectorman and others(you may add Sparkster, Zero the Kamikaze Squirrel, Aero the Acro-Bat, Pulseman, Zool) are cartoonish.
The only one, who can actually break the wall between those clashing styles is Sketch(well, maybe some sonic evildoer can, but I dunno, it's not for my liking, very used) - if you are going to make one game with both humans and cartoonish animals in it it's not a bad idea to make story around Sketch, with him and some other people from real world being transferred into bizarre comix world... or something like this.

Then I suppose super smash brothers doesnt work as a game either...

[ExeLord]

Never liked that... Matter of tastes.

[DanOwnsall112]

It could work just fine if done right.

[GaryCXJk]

Apparently Selvaria Bles is the most popular character from Valkyria Chronicles, so if you guys don't pick her to represent Valkyria Chronicles, I'll murder you dead.

[HyperVoiceActing]

The only one, who can actually break the wall between those clashing styles is Sketch(well, maybe some sonic evildoer can, but I dunno, it's not for my liking, very used)

I did put Eggman in my roster.

Also I don't see why people seem to think only realistic chars should be in crossovers like this. Shouldn't games like this have their best chars, regardless of design. Smash Bros wouldn't be the same without Mario and I bet the same can be said with a Sega inner crossover and Sonic

[ZVitor]

i belive this old proect was droped:
http://forum.paodemugen.com.br/index.php?showtopic=2060

or this one:
https://sites.google.com/site/oldschoolmugen/

maybe you could get some already done work there.

[HyperVoiceActing]

That first one uses original Genesis sprites, I mean bigger sprites made just for project

[Ganbare-Lucifer]

AMIGO! AMIGO! AMIGO! AMIGO!

Without the "n" of course... if not...

[-Whiplash-]

Never liked that... Matter of tastes.

MVC Did it too.

[HyperVoiceActing]

MVC Did it too.

And my guess is he didn't like it then too.

he and Skeletor would really get along

[ExeLord]

I've talked about Smash Bros. when I look at Samus, Mario and Mr. Game And Watch it's gives me wtf reaction.
In MvC it wasn't like that, Mega Man and Tron looks childish, not cartoonish. If you were talking about X-Men and others(including Shuma-Gorath and Anakaris) if they are not humans(/mutants) they are monsters/demons, but nothing like stuffed animals. Servobot was exception, but it was joke char as was Norimaru(slightly different from others - cartoonish and removed from non-jap versions of game).
Hmmm, you know what? You saw Mario and Marco(from Metal Slug) in SNK style? If Sonic and others would be style united it might work well(though they'll be rather strange mutants/aliens/guests from parallel worlds/etc.). If not, then as I said - Sketch and others are trapped in comics world or Eggman or someone else from Sonic's universe forced Sonic and others travel to world of humans for unknown purpose... Second one have more questions, like why that someone did that and all so I like first one better(concept from Orochi Warriors about just beating a crap out of strongest warriors probably won't do it). Concept of making them toys in imaginary world... naw, not really good thing.

[HyperVoiceActing]

So you think Smash Bros would be better if it was just Link, Samus, and Cap. Falcon or just Mario, Pikachu, and DK? It wouldn't be a crossover of Nintendo's finest if they only include the realistic looking or cartoonish looking in the roster and no one else. And I feel the same applys here. If you heard there was a crossover of all of Sega's best chars and you only saw realstic chars like Axel Stone and Akuri Yuki you'd probably be like "Where's Sonic? He's the devildamn mascot!" or whatnot.

[ExeLord]

Naw, I can't care less about Sonic I prefer gameplay over brands. It's good to have mascot, but nothing good to stick it in everything fits he or not. As example:

Quoting DanOwnsall112:It could work just fine if done right.
I'm not against it in every way, there ways to make it so it won't cause urge to split it in two games or just remove half of roster. Combining cartoonish ones with realistic ones without changing style for any of those sides also making damage to screen pack and stages - making it stylish, realistic makes cartoonish chars out of place, making it cartoonish - vice versa.

[HyperVoiceActing]

The sprites styles don't have to clash, they can be sprites in the same style but I don't see why they can't contain their look

[GaryCXJk]

If you're doing Versus style, I might consider helping out with a few sprites. Of course, being the busy man I am (read: I'm a programmer, procrastination is my profession), I might not be able to work on stuff full-time, but at least I can provide the bases for characters.