MvC Bombman I need Crit

[Esʞy]

OK, here is Manic's Bombman with a little of my editing for a stance.. and I need peoples opinions on it. What needs to be changed or what doesn't look right. I really need criticism it would help soooooo much! TY
1.
or
2.
or
3.
or Manic's Original with a flipped bomb
4.
or Manic's Original with a little editing.
5.

[Jesuscroid]

I don't know if I can give critism, the sprite itself looks excellent to me,
the 2 stances I like the most is 3 and 5

[laspacho]

I like Stance 3, that would be fitting.
All of these came out really nice. If it were me I wouldn't have him hold a bomb in his stance though, that would be a pain to put into every sprite.  Sprite 1 and 5 would make awesome attacks for Bombman.  I love how he is holding the bomb in sprite 1.   

[viteoz]

 I like the number 3. ^^

[Danoartist]

   They look cool, I would love to see a stance were he holds a bomb I think 1 was my first thought but if it isn't practical don't try it.

[Esʞy]

Wow final some crit ... but yeah I agree with laspacho it would be a pain in the butt to do every sprite with a bomb so I think 3 and the rest will be attacks or a start to a super or even hyper.

[Rage]

Wow final some crit ... but yeah I agree with laspacho it would be a pain in the butt to do every sprite with a bomb so I think 3 and the rest will be attacks or a start to a super or even hyper.

Good Ideal, my wip Axl is a pain because of the gun is in every frame. 

[Esʞy]

Good Ideal, my wip Axl is a pain because of the gun is in every frame.  

Yeah, doing all the punch, kick and jump sprites would just be a hassle!  So I'm gunna take advice and not make my life a living hell..

[Manic]

Fixed up the shading a bit on your third sprite so that it isn't pillowed anymore.

[LunaG]

But the original will always have more feel to it...

[Esʞy]

Fixed up the shading a bit on your third sprite so that it isn't pillowed anymore.

TY Manic..

[jurk]

The pictures from 3 to 5 have some weird shadowing in the legs (for me at least). It seems like the leg on the left of the picture ison a farer plane

[Acey]

It looks good, my only thing is that Bombman is typically presenting a little pudgier in the midwaiste section.

[Esʞy]

It looks good, my only thing is that Bombman is typically presenting a little pudgier in the midwaiste section.

Okay so a little more pudgy.

[G.P.O.A - GatlingPunchRalf]

I like where this is going. I always did love his obsession with explosions.

[Esʞy]

The pictures from 3 to 5 have some weird shadowing in the legs (for me at least). It seems like the leg on the left of the picture ison a farer plane

Okay, I get you h/o I will fix it.
EDIT:
Okay, how about this -

He's pudgier or should he put on a few more pounds  and Manic already fix the shading.

[SolidZone 26]

Yeah, I kinda agree with laspacho. I like the 3rd one too. Make him only carry a bomb when he's doing a special, not during his stance.

[Esʞy]

Ok I need help I think this looks funny. -

[Rage]

Ok I need help I think this looks funny. -

wats wrong with it? it looks perfectly fine too me.

[Esʞy]

wats wrong with it? it looks perfectly fine too me.

idk it just really looks funny, I just wanted a second opinion.
Maybe an Intro.. He comes in thinking he is tough and the bombs fall out from underneath him..

[Jesuscroid]

Ok I need help I think this looks funny. -

3rd frame looks like he is fat (is that how BombMan is supposed to be?), and still in the 3rd frame, his face (or head) is just not right, try comparing it with the head from your standing frame and try to fix it

[Excursion]

It looks good, my only thing is that Bombman is typically presenting a little pudgier in the midwaiste section.

I did an edit a while back that some remember. This was my take on Bombman:



Based off this image:



From this thread (pg. 3):

http://www.infinitymugenteam.com/Forum_345/index.php?topic=25649.30

[Esʞy]

I did an edit a while back that some remember. This was my take on Bombman:



Based off this image:



From this thread (pg. 3):

http://www.infinitymugenteam.com/Forum_345/index.php?topic=25649.30

That's a awesome edit!!!!  
So ISDK Should I make him bigger and then whats a good base? I know Megaman and Duo maybe?
There are these -

[Excursion]

Megaman, Power Battles Gutsman:



and from scratch editing were my bases.

[Esʞy]

Yeah that'll work.. I'll have the first sprite done on the morrow.
Thanx Excursion